Before you book: compare three creators
An editable QuickAds decision kit. Use it to choose a pilot and identify what still needs checking. The sample is fictional; it does not describe the creators in the accompanying Remy capture.
Start with the job
Brand / product: ____________________
Target buyer and country: ____________________
What are you buying? Content only / creator distribution / both
Deliverables, platforms, dates and budget cap: ____________________
What must the creator demonstrate or explain credibly? ____________________
The worked example
Illustrative brief: a US walking-shoe brand wants an Instagram creator post and a product demonstration for everyday walkers. The goal is to learn whether the creator can explain the fit and show the shoe clearly. The first booking is a bounded pilot, not a sales forecast.
| Evidence | Creator A | Creator B | Creator C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quote | $1,200 | $800 | $450 |
| Scope | Content + one post | Content + one post | Content only |
| Followers | 120,000 | 45,000 | Not used for this comparison |
| Median views, last 12 comparable posts | 9,000 | 15,000 | Not applicable to purchased distribution |
| Quote per 1,000 historical median views | $133.33 | $53.33 | Not comparable |
| Relevant content | General fitness | Footwear explanations | Strong product close-ups |
| Buyer geography | Not confirmed | Not confirmed | Not relevant to a content-only purchase |
| Usage / permissions | Confirm | Confirm | Confirm |
| Next decision | Ask for audience evidence | First candidate to verify for a distribution pilot | Consider separately for production |
Calculation: (quote ÷ median historical views) × 1,000. This is a scope-dependent historical cost comparison, not actual campaign CPM or predicted reach. It allocates the full quote to historical views for a simple first comparison, although the quote may include production. A and B must have matched deliverables before using it. A median is not an expected future result.
The decision memo
First candidate to verify: B. B combines a lower matched-scope quote with stronger recent viewing evidence and a closer content fit. Those facts justify the next verification step, not an automatic booking.
Hold the booking until: target-country audience evidence is checked; the last 12 posts are reviewed for comparability and sponsorship differences; dates, editing, revisions, distribution and paid-use scope are confirmed; and the brand reviews a relevant demonstration.
Keep C in a separate production lane. If we only need footage for the brand's own ads, C may be the more useful choice. A distribution comparison should not reject a content-only producer for having no purchased audience reach.
What would change the decision? If A has much better verified buyer overlap or B cannot credibly demonstrate the product, the provisional order may reverse. If both lack enough evidence, do not book yet.
Your blank comparison
Use aliases in a shared copy. Keep private contact details and correspondence outside the worksheet.
| Field | Candidate 1 | Candidate 2 | Candidate 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source profile URL + date checked | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Purchase: content / distribution / both | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Exact deliverables | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Quote + currency | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Last 12 comparable post links | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Median and mean views; outliers noted | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Buyer overlap: evidence + source | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Content fit: example + reason | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Product demonstration quality | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Usage, posting and authorization scope | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Availability and delivery date | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Unknowns / requested evidence | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Provisional next action | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
Evidence rules
Separate public observation, creator-supplied dashboard evidence, modelled estimates and unknowns. A public comment pattern does not establish fraud. A fit badge is a recommendation to inspect, not proof of a good booking. Do not collapse different purchase types into one universal creator score.
Ask an assistant to help
Paste your completed rows and use this instruction:
Compare these candidates for the brief above. First separate content-only production from audience distribution. Check scope comparability, missing values, post comparability, audience evidence and usage terms. Calculate only what the supplied numbers support. Do not invent metrics, label an account fake or forecast sales. Return: first candidate to verify, evidence for that choice, missing checks, what would reverse the decision, and the next action. If evidence is insufficient, say so.
Turn the choice into a pilot brief
Selected candidate / owner: ____________________
Hypothesis: ____________________
Opening / product demonstration / proof / CTA: ____________________
Approved claims and their evidence: ____________________
Deliverables, rights, dates, revisions and cap: ____________________
Primary metric and observation window: ____________________
What remains unchanged against the control: ____________________
Continue with QuickAds
If you have the brief but not a shortlist, Remy can help with the creator search. Confirm the current service scope and any booking terms before proceeding. The worksheet itself is free to use, with no comment, connection or account gate.