One-Brief Platform Comparison Kit
Evaluate suppliers against the campaign you need to run. This kit produces a shortlist with evidence and trade-offs, not a universal vendor score.
Fix the brief first
Write the product, customer, market, platform, creator job, deliverables, intended usage, available internal operator and campaign constraints. Use the identical brief in every demo. Keep software access, creator payments and human services separate.
Worked example
Fictional buyer and suppliers: a two-person app team needs three creators to demonstrate a feature. It has a product approver but little coordination capacity. The supplier descriptions below are invented to show how to record findings; they are not findings about Modash, Aspire, SideShift, Trybe or QuickAds.
| Requirement | Illustrative supplier A finding | Illustrative supplier B finding | Source / confidence in this example | Fit decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Relevant creator evidence | Demo opens a relevant video; audience geography not shown | Proposal promises a shortlist; no candidate evidence reviewed | A: observed demo only. B: proposal statement only. Neither establishes campaign outcomes. | A supports an initial research check; ask both for audience evidence |
| Daily coordination | Written scope leaves it with buyer | Written pilot proposal includes named coordinator | Fictional written proposals; inclusion still needs final agreement | B better matches limited buyer capacity if the scope is confirmed |
| Rejected video | Demo shows a feedback record; no revision obligation stated | One factual correction round stated | Interface observation versus contractual obligation are different evidence | Clarify A's revision scope and B's creative-change exclusions |
| Paid usage | Fee and duration unresolved | Duration specified, identity-based ad permission excluded | Written scope in the fictional example | Neither is ready for identity-based paid use |
| Cost | Subscription quoted; buyer hours missing | Service fee quoted; creator fees separate | Incomplete cost records | Request matched full-cost proposals; do not rank price yet |
| Outcome evidence | No campaign result inspected | A testimonial shown | Neither independently verifies performance for this brief | Do not claim a performance winner |
Example recommendation: progress B to a scope discussion because its proposed coordination matches the staffing gap. Keep A in consideration if the buyer can supply an operator. Resolve rights, evidence and complete cost before buying either.
Evidence table to reuse
| Supplier / plan | Required task | Claim or finding | Exact source URL / document / demo time | Checked date | Evidence type and limits | Fit for this brief | Missing proof / next action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enter your record | Discovery and screening | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Enter your record | Outreach and coordination | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Enter your record | Review and revisions | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Enter your record | Rights and payments | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Enter your record | Reporting and export | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
| Enter your record | Total scoped cost | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record | Enter your record |
Supplier starting points: Modash, Aspire, SideShift, Trybe and QuickAds. These links are research starting points, not proof that any feature or service is included in a plan.
Record confidence without fake precision
Use observed in demo, written scope, vendor-stated, buyer-reported, or not checked. A demonstration supports what you saw; it does not confirm every plan includes it. A written proposal supports scope; it does not prove delivery quality. Record both when possible. Do not turn these labels into invented numerical quality scores.
Your final output: shortlist / request clarification / exclude for this brief, with one reason and one unresolved condition for each supplier. A supplier can be a poor fit for this campaign without being a poor product.